Who would win?

Joshua Allen is generally considered the better quarterback currently. His combination of arm strength, mobility, and improved accuracy gives him an edge. He has also shown more consistent high-level play, especially in critical games and moments. Allen's impact on his team has been substantial, leading the Buffalo Bills to significant success and demonstrating high potential as a franchise quarterback. Allen has a clearer trajectory as a top-tier quarterback, while Mayfield has shown potential but has faced more ups and downs.